Best MemberPress Alternatives in 2026 (Ranked)

Last Updated: May 2026

MemberPress is a WordPress plugin, not a hosted SaaS. That single fact reshapes the shortlist. If your team does not want to self-host WordPress, patch security, and manage hosting on top of running a membership, then the best MemberPress alternatives are hosted platforms. Most “alternatives” lists hide a second issue: three of the most-recommended swaps (MemberMouse, WishList Member, and AccessAlly) are owned by Caseproof, the same parent company that owns MemberPress. Switching to those keeps you with the same vendor. Below we rank 9 genuine options, with a focus on associations, nonprofits, creators, and clubs that need more than a content paywall. Want to compare against more options beyond MemberPress? Start with the alternatives hub.

Why organizations look for MemberPress alternatives

MemberPress is a competent paywall plugin. The reasons organizations leave are rarely about the feature itself. They are about the operating model around it. Five themes recur in association buyer conversations and in public reviews.

1. Admin lockout when the license lapses. WP Tavern documented that MemberPress disables admin access to membership settings when the subscription is not renewed. Public WordPress users have repeated this complaint in 2022 and 2023. A plugin you paid for last year can stop letting you manage members this year. That is a structural risk most SaaS platforms do not create, because the data stays accessible even on a downgrade.

2. The 4.9 percent transaction fee on Launch. The entry plan ($199.50 annual intro, renewing at $399) takes 4.9 percent of every transaction. On $20,000 of annual member revenue that fee is $980. On $50,000 it is $2,450. That is well above the plugin price. Removing the fee requires moving to Growth at $349.50 intro and $699 renewal.

3. WordPress hosting and security burden. MemberPress only runs on self-hosted WordPress. The buyer also pays for hosting, SSL, backups, plugin updates, and security monitoring. For a 10-person association, that operating cost can match the membership tool itself.

4. Roughly 2x renewal pricing. All three MemberPress tiers are sold at intro prices that roughly double on renewal: Launch $199.50 to $399, Growth $349.50 to $699, Scale $499.50 to $999. Budgets set in year one rarely match year two.

5. The Caseproof acquisition pattern. MemberPress’s parent company has acquired multiple competitors. WishList Member joined Caseproof in 2022, and AccessAlly joined in 2024. MemberMouse is also part of the portfolio. So three of the top “alternatives” search results are sister products. Association buyers in our sales conversations regularly raise this as a reason to look outside the Caseproof family entirely.

What to look for in a MemberPress alternative

Before reviewing the platforms, decide which of the following matter for your use case. The shortlist of 9 below maps cleanly to these criteria, but not every option scores well on every dimension.

• Hosted platform option. Do you want a SaaS that handles hosting, updates, and security, or are you happy maintaining a WordPress stack?
• Transparent transaction-fee policy. Some tools charge a flat fee with 0 percent on payments. Others (including MemberPress Launch) take a percentage of every transaction.
• No admin lockout when subscription lapses. Read-only access on a downgrade is acceptable. Full backend lockout is a red flag.
• Built-in CRM, events, dues, and email. If you need more than content gating, a paywall tool is the wrong category. Look at AMS or SaaS membership platforms.
• Member-facing mobile app. If you serve a community, a branded iOS and Android app is now a baseline expectation, not a luxury.
• Ownership stability outside the Caseproof portfolio. If consolidation risk concerns you, exclude MemberMouse, WishList Member, and AccessAlly.

The Best MemberPress Alternatives in 2026

1. Raklet

Founded 2013 · Privately held · 10+ employees

Raklet is a hosted SaaS that combines membership management, CRM, events, email broadcasts, dues collection, and a custom-branded mobile app in a single platform. It was built specifically for associations, nonprofits, alumni networks, and professional communities that need to manage people, not just gate content. There are no transaction fees on membership payments inside Raklet’s billing flow. Because everything sits in one system, you do not need to wire MemberPress to a separate CRM, a separate event tool, and a separate mailer.

You can compare Raklet to MemberPress head-to-head for the feature-by-feature breakdown.

Pricing: Contact-based, tailored to organization size and modules. See Raklet pricing plans.
Best for: associations and nonprofits that need more than content gating.

2. Memberful

Acquired by Patreon 2021 · Hosted SaaS · 20+ employees

Memberful is a hosted membership platform tightly integrated with Stripe. It started as a creator-focused alternative to building a custom paywall and was acquired by Patreon in 2021. It is simpler than MemberPress on purpose: paywall, member accounts, email lists, and Stripe billing. There is no LMS, no event registration, and no AMS depth. For a solo creator running a paid newsletter, a podcast, or a small video membership, that simplicity is the appeal.

Pricing: Free tier with revenue share, Pro $25/mo, Premium $100/mo (see memberful.com/pricing).
Best for: solo creators selling paid newsletters or podcasts.

3. Paid Memberships Pro

Founded 2010 · Independent · Open-source

Paid Memberships Pro (PMP) is a free WordPress membership plugin with paid add-ons. It is the closest direct replacement for MemberPress on the WordPress stack, and it is genuinely independent. One useful property: the core code continues to function after a paid license expires. You lose access to updates and support, but you do not get locked out of administering your members. That alone is enough reason for many WordPress-native buyers to choose PMP over MemberPress.

Pricing: Free core; Plus $297/yr; Unlimited $597/yr (per paidmembershipspro.com).
Best for: developers who want full control and budget-conscious WordPress sites.

4. Mighty Networks

Founded 2017 · VC-backed (Series B 2021) · Hosted SaaS

Mighty Networks is a community-first hosted platform with paid memberships, native courses, live events, and a branded mobile app. The pitch is different from MemberPress: instead of gating WordPress content, you build a standalone community space where the membership and the discussion are the product. It works well for cohort-based programs, creator communities, and paid masterminds. It is less suited to traditional clubs with dues and a board.

Pricing: Community $41/mo, Business $99/mo, Path-to-Pro $360/mo.
Best for: creators building a paid community with content and discussion.

5. ClubExpress

Founded 2004 · Privately held · Hosted SaaS

ClubExpress is a hosted AMS used heavily by small to mid-sized clubs and traditional associations. Pricing is per-member per month and scales from around $0.10 to $0.85 per member depending on add-on modules. Buyer reviews on Capterra consistently rate ClubExpress strongly for small clubs and small associations evaluating MemberPress alternatives. The UI is dated but the feature depth (dues, committees, events, directory) is well beyond a content paywall.

Pricing: Per-member monthly fee, roughly $0.10 to $0.85 per member per month (see ClubExpress pricing).
Best for: traditional clubs and small associations under 5,000 members.

6. MemberSpace

Founded 2017 · Independent · Hosted SaaS

MemberSpace is an overlay membership tool. Instead of running on WordPress only, it adds gated access on top of any site, including Squarespace, Webflow, WordPress, and custom HTML. You keep your existing site design and CMS and bolt on member accounts, paywalls, and Stripe billing. It is independent and has been steadily updated since 2017.

Pricing: Pro $25/mo, Plus $75/mo, Premier $250/mo (per memberspace.com).
Best for: anyone who wants to add memberships to an existing site without rebuilding.

7. Wild Apricot

Founded 2006 · Owned by Personify (PE) · 100+ employees

Wild Apricot is the entry-level AMS most small associations consider first. It is hosted SaaS, owned by Personify (a PE-backed AMS rollup), and priced by contact count. Pricing starts at $69/mo for the Group tier (up to 100 contacts) and climbs to $730/mo for Global (up to 50,000 contacts). It includes dues, events, an emailer, a directory, and a website builder, which is exactly the bundle MemberPress lacks. Reviews flag that the UI is dated and the support is mixed.

Pricing: $69/mo (Group, 100 contacts) to $730/mo (Global, 50,000 contacts) per wildapricot.com pricing.
Best for: small to mid-sized associations that have outgrown spreadsheets.

8. Circle

Founded 2019 · VC-backed · Hosted SaaS

Circle is a community plus courses platform popular with creators, course operators, and accelerator programs. It overlaps with Mighty Networks but leans more toward cohort programs, podcast communities, and creator brands. Member experience is polished. It is not designed for traditional AMS workflows like committees or dues invoices.

Pricing: Basic $49/mo, Professional $99/mo, Business $219/mo, Enterprise by quote (per circle.so).
Best for: cohort-based courses and creator communities.

9. A note on the Caseproof portfolio

MemberMouse · WishList Member · AccessAlly · same parent as MemberPress

You will find many “best MemberPress alternatives” lists that recommend MemberMouse, WishList Member, or AccessAlly. All three are owned by Caseproof, the same parent company that owns MemberPress. The WishList Member acquisition closed in 2022 and the AccessAlly acquisition closed in 2024. Switching from MemberPress to any of these means staying with the same vendor and the same renewal economics. If you are evaluating MemberPress because you want to diversify away from Caseproof, exclude these three.

MemberPress Alternatives Compared

Prices as of May 2026 based on published pricing pages. Quote-based figures are ranges from verified customer reports.

View full screen ↗

What does each platform cost at your member count?

Prices as of May 2026 based on published pricing pages. Quote-based figures are ranges from verified customer reports.

View full screen ↗

Which MemberPress alternative is right for you?

If you run an association, nonprofit, alumni network, or professional community, the membership tool is only one part of the job. You also need a CRM, an event registration flow, a dues engine, a member directory, and an email broadcaster. Raklet was built for this profile and includes all of these in one platform along with a branded mobile app. ClubExpress and Wild Apricot also cover the AMS bundle, with Wild Apricot stronger on website builder and ClubExpress stronger on traditional club workflows.

If you are a solo creator, podcaster, or newsletter writer, you do not need an AMS. Memberful is the simplest option and integrates cleanly with Stripe. Mighty Networks and Circle go further if you also want a community space and live events around the paid content.

If you are committed to WordPress and want a direct plugin swap, Paid Memberships Pro is the closest functional replacement for MemberPress and is genuinely independent. The core code keeps working after a license lapses, which removes the lockout risk specifically. MemberSpace is a useful option if you do not want a WordPress-only solution and need to gate content on Squarespace, Webflow, or a custom site.

If you would rather test a hosted SaaS than spend the afternoon comparing pricing pages, the fastest move is to Try Raklet free.

FAQ

What is the best MemberPress alternative?

There is no single best alternative because MemberPress serves three buyer types at once: paid-content creators, course operators, and small associations. For associations and nonprofits, Raklet is the best fit because it bundles CRM, events, dues, email, and a mobile app. For solo creators, Memberful is simpler. For WordPress-native sites that want a direct plugin swap, Paid Memberships Pro is the closest match.

What’s the cheapest MemberPress alternative?

The cheapest entry point is Paid Memberships Pro, which has a free core plugin with optional paid add-ons starting at $297 per year for Plus. Memberful is also low cost with a free tier that charges a per-transaction revenue share until you upgrade to Pro at $25 per month. For most under-1,000-member sites, both options come in below MemberPress Growth’s $699 renewal price.

Is there a free MemberPress alternative?

Yes. Paid Memberships Pro publishes a free core plugin in the WordPress repository with no time limit. Memberful offers a free plan that charges a revenue share on member payments instead of a flat fee. WordPress also has free membership plugins like Restrict Content and Simple Membership. None of these match MemberPress’s full feature set, but they are real free options for small sites.

How long does it take to migrate from MemberPress?

A simple migration with under 1,000 members and one or two membership tiers typically takes 1 to 2 weeks. A larger migration with custom roles, drip content, and historical billing data takes 4 to 8 weeks. The longest single step is reconciling Stripe customers and active subscriptions on the new platform. Most hosted SaaS providers, including Raklet, offer a guided onboarding flow that handles the member import and the Stripe re-attach.

What’s the best MemberPress alternative for an association or nonprofit?

For associations and nonprofits, the best fit is a hosted AMS, not a paywall plugin. Raklet is purpose-built for this audience and includes CRM, events, dues, email broadcasts, and a branded mobile app in one platform. ClubExpress and Wild Apricot are also genuine AMS options. All three remove the WordPress hosting and security burden that comes with MemberPress and add the bundle features associations need.

The Bottom Line on MemberPress Alternatives

Pick by what you need beyond a paywall. Associations and nonprofits should evaluate Raklet first because the CRM, events, dues, and mobile app are part of the platform rather than separate purchases. Solo creators and podcasters should look at Memberful for the cleanest Stripe-integrated paywall. Budget-conscious WordPress sites that want to stay on WordPress should evaluate Paid Memberships Pro, which is independent of Caseproof and keeps working after a license lapse. Any short list that includes MemberMouse, WishList Member, or AccessAlly is not a list of alternatives, because all three are sister products under the same parent.

Compare to Other Membership Software Alternatives